Overlooked scoring guard turned a D2 program's top recruit
A high-scoring guard on a small-town HS team that never got AAU exposure with the big circuits. Great player, great grades, zero D1 interest, and running out of time. We reframed her fit toward strong D2 programs where she'd actually play — and one of them made her a priority.
- Athlete
- Maya R. · Class of 2026
- Position
- Combo Guard · 5'8"
- Home
- Ohio
- Aid value
- ~$28,000 / year (partial athletic + presidential academic)
3.9 / 32 ACT
GPA
26
Programs contacted
11 head coaches
Real conversations
3 D2, 4 D3
Written offers
Where they started
The situation
- Believed D1 was the only 'real' scholarship — hadn't considered D2 seriously
- AAU program didn't travel to events D1 coaches attended
- Family was quietly panicking as junior year ended with no offers
- Highlight tape was a music-video edit — great buckets, no context
The plan we ran
What we actually did
Step 1
Reset the definition of success
We walked the family through what a partial D2 offer plus academic aid actually looks like — often more real money than a 25% D1 offer at a private school. That reframing opened up 20+ schools she'd dismissed.
Step 2
Built a coach-friendly film
Recut her tape by skill: pick-and-roll reads first, then pull-up, then defense. Coaches don't want a 6-minute mixtape — they want to answer one question in 90 seconds.
Step 3
Targeted programs by need
We researched which D2 rosters were losing guards and which had recent transfer-portal losses. She emailed programs with an actual roster hole she could fill.
Step 4
Set up unofficial visits
Three campus visits before senior year. She walked into the season with real relationships and a coach texting her scores every Friday night.
The turning point
Her eventual head coach flew in to watch a regular-season HS game — because we'd been sending him her stat lines and film clips every week for three months. He offered on the drive home.
The result
Where they ended up
- Committed in October of senior year
- Named a program priority — will compete for immediate minutes
- Academic money brings total aid close to the value of a full ride
- Two other D2 programs kept the offer open until signing day
"Kito was the first person who told us the truth: she was a great D2 player, not a mid-major D1 player, and that was going to be a better life. He was right. She's exactly where she should be."
Ready to write your case study?
Tell us where your athlete is today. We'll show you what a plan looks like from here.
Book a free strategy call